Score
Shield Roofing & Solar reviews
• updated MAR 31, 2026Loading map...
The Verdict
Shield Roofing is run by a husband-and-wife team who show up at job sites to vacuum for loose nails. We analyzed over a hundred reviews and found just one mention of subpar value and one complaint about workmanship, while 140 reviewers singled out installation quality and 133 praised how projects were run. You won't find a cheaper quote elsewhere, and the company occasionally stumbles on insurance coordination (one homeowner described a claim process where the Shield rep backtracked after initially expressing confidence), but the core work holds up. In one review, a retired Fortune 500 construction executive who formerly managed a building division wrote a 400-word endorsement calling Shield "a master at their craft." What stood out most was warranty follow-through: reviewers mention free same-day leak repairs years after installation, on-site owner involvement during final walkthroughs, and crews who protect landscaping with tarps before the first shingle comes off. If you want an installer who'll return your texts at 8 p.m. and personally inspect the magnet sweep for nails, this is that company.
If you're comparing purely on price, you may find a lower quote elsewhere. But if you want an installer who'll come back two years later to patch a small leak for free, the premium is worth it.
3 Stories That Stood Out
Bradley met with Patrick, the owner, to walk through every option for the roof repair and installation on his home—products, pros and cons, and what to expect from the insurance process. Patrick stayed reachable by phone and text, guided him through the quality differences, and left him confident in the choices he made. On install day Leo, the supervisor, came onsite to explain each line item as the work progressed, handled a few questions and potential issues as they arose, and at the end of the day reviewed all the completed work. Leo also shared drone photos of the roof—something that excited the kids. The crew arrived on time, helped move and cover things Bradley hadn’t thought to protect, and worked hard from about 6:00 AM until 8:00 PM in roughly 100-degree heat. They finished by cleaning thoroughly, checking for loose nails, and actually leaving the property cleaner than when they arrived. Bradley walked away impressed enough to recommend Shield Roofing and Contracting to others; what stuck with him most was the crew’s endurance and the meticulous cleanup after a very long, hot day.
Mark W., a retired president and former licensed builder and commercial design engineer, hired Shield Roofing to replace the roof and install a new gutter system on his home in the DFW area about 30 days ago. With roughly 30 years of overseeing residential and commercial builds — including running the building division for the nation’s largest news company and serving as a managing executive at Starline, one of the country’s largest building and kitchen design centers — he inspected the project with a very seasoned eye. He found the workmanship excellent: a clean roof and gutter installation completed at a competitive price and backed by a comprehensive warranty. What made the experience memorable for him, beyond the finished product, was the owners, Patrick and Shannon — their kindness, straightforward honesty, and steady follow-through. After a career watching both stellar and poor contractors, he judged Shield Roofing to be a master of their craft and a top option in DFW for roofing, solar and gutter work. Thirty days out, he remained impressed by the quality, the owners’ integrity, and the strength of the warranty — the exact details he values after decades in the building and設
Sarah M spent more than a year working with Shield over damage to her roof, watching company reps climb up three separate times and repeatedly insist they could win a hail claim — even an appeal — so she wouldn’t have to worry about an insurance premium spike. Nervous about filing, she finally went ahead after that third inspection because Shield kept telling her there was enough evidence to submit a claim. When the inspection day arrived she asked to reschedule after a family death and was told she didn’t need to be present; the insurer went out, inspected, and denied the claim. She later learned from the Allstate agent that the Shield representative hadn’t even been on the roof until after the insurer finished their inspection, despite earlier promises that they would inspect side-by-side and point out the damage. After the denial the rep reversed course, saying there wasn’t enough to appeal, which left her stunned — the bold confidence that prompted her to file evaporated into reluctance to contest the decision. She won’t single out the individual who came to the house, but what stuck with her was that repeated assurances gave way to inaction, and she ended up with a denied hail
Platforms Monitored
Performance by Work Type
How We Got To Trust Score 89
Clean Record
Unauthorized Activities
Passed screening
Misleading Claims
Passed screening
Background Check
Serving customers for 6 years
BBB Rating: A+
Excellent BBB standing. Strong complaint resolution.
Natural Review Patterns
Reviews were posted naturally over time.
What You Can Expect
Melanie has relied on Shield Roofing for all of her clients' roofing work for years, bringing them in for every job across DWF. She found them consistently honest and dependable, with a level of follow-through that stood out — they showed up, completed the work as promised, and handled the finishing details without leaving surprises. Pricing proved accurate every time, with no hidden fees, so billing stayed straightforward for her clients. She intends to keep using Shield Roofing for future projects because of that dependable follow-through paired with transparent pricing.
Greg Miller hadn't been looking for solar, but when Patrick at Shield Roofing & Solar put together an offer he couldn't refuse, he changed course. Patrick stayed involved from start to finish, navigating approvals and installation while accommodating Greg's exacting preferences. One non-negotiable was a continuous thermal barrier beneath the roof to improve insulation and reduce HVAC use; Shield installed that across the whole roof. They paired conventional GAF shingles with matching Timberline flat solar shingles, which blend into the roofline and look far less conspicuous than the bulky panels all over the neighborhood. The HOA signed off quickly, the project proceeded smoothly, and he ended up with a nearly invisible solar roof plus the added insulation — the two features that made the whole switch worthwhile.
Sherri began the process wanting a straightforward solar installation and found Shields honest and informative from the very first contact through project completion. She watched their team answer questions plainly and deliver what she described as high-quality workmanship on the roof and connections. The combination of clear communication during planning and tidy, solid installation stuck with her — the detail that made the whole experience feel reliable and worth recommending.
Megan began working with Shield in the fall of 2021 after significant hail damaged her roof. Shield arranged a full roof repair and upgraded the shingles. Since then they have returned twice to fix small leaks, repairing them at no charge and completing the work the same day. She values the warranty and the quick follow-up and plans to keep using Shield — the same-day, free repairs under warranty are the detail that stood out.
Barbara hired the company for a full roof replacement and ended up with a roof that looks beautiful and is clearly higher quality than the one it replaced. She leaned on Patrick throughout the insurance-claim process, with him staying involved from start to finish. The installation crew worked courteously and efficiently, and both Patrick and his wife came by at the end to make sure the job was completed correctly and to pitch in with cleanup. This is the third roof she’s had, and thanks to the workmanship and the standout warranties, she expects this one to last her for a very long time.
Jimmi turned to Shield Roofing & Solar for a full roof replacement and a solar installation on their home, and ended up with both finished cleanly and to their satisfaction. They found the office staff consistently professional and kind, and the installation crew worked efficiently and respectfully on the property. The most memorable part of the experience was working with Patrick and Shannon — honest, hard‑working Christians who treated the project personally and made coordination painless. In the end, the combination of a solid roof job, a well-executed solar install, and a team whose integrity showed through is what stayed with them.
Wing Choi turned to Shield for solar work on several occasions and found they consistently met his expectations. He relied on them more than once and walked away each time satisfied—the defining detail being steady, predictable results rather than flashes of brilliance. For someone who values repeatable, dependable service from the same installer, that reliability is the takeaway.
Allan McKeever hired Shield Roofing to repair the roof valleys and fit new flashings on his house. He watched the crew work carefully, left the job site tidy, and paid what he called a very reasonable price. He appreciated getting dependable valley repairs without an inflated bill, and he plans to call them again when the next roof job comes up — the tidy valley flashings and fair cost are what stuck with him.
After comparing several local roofing quotes, Yu Sun landed on Patrick Johnson for a roof replacement. They found Patrick professional, responsive, and easy to work with; his project manager and crew carried out the roof work skillfully, and the finished roof looks great so far. The price wasn’t the cheapest, but the higher cost translated into noticeably professional workmanship. Patrick even returned personally after the job to verify the site was cleaned up properly — a touch of hands-on follow-through they appreciated. In the end, they paid a bit more and walked away with a neatly completed roof and a contractor who made sure the cleanup met his own standards.
Long-term Satisfaction
Long-term satisfaction for Shield Roofing & Solar holds steady at 5.0 ★. This is better than 77% of installers we looked at.
Long-term reviews carry the most weight in our methodology because they are most representative of what you should be paying for: a system that will perform for years.